[Skip to Content]


Location Info

Our location map
2332 E. 116th Street
Carmel, IN 46032
Look for stores with the Gold Standard Seal. They have been recognized for achieving the highest standards in Product, Quality, Operations and Customer Service.
This store accepts gift cards

Store Hours

Mon:10:00 AM - 07:00 PM
Tues:10:00 AM - 07:00 PM
Wed:10:00 AM - 07:00 PM
Thu:10:00 AM - 07:00 PM
Fri:10:00 AM - 07:00 PM
Sat:10:00 AM - 06:00 PM
Sun:12:00 PM - 05:00 PM

Contact Store


for News and Promotions

We Share Your Passion For Sports!

Play It Again Sports - Carmel-Fishers Montage

At Play It Again Sports in Carmel & Fishers we specialize in Fitness, Golf, Baseball, Softball, Hockey, Lacrosse, Football, Disc Golf, Soccer, Skiing, Snowboarding, Water Sports and much more. If you are looking to buy or sell new or slightly used sports and fitness equipment, Play It Again Sports in Carmel or in Fishers should be your first stop.

We are different from the "Big Box" sporting goods stores in that we are a family owned and operated business. We care about local families because we are locally owned.

When it comes to fitting you or your family with just the right sports equipment, we know our stuff. Our staff members are trained to provide athletes with the best possible fit in the gear they need to play the game. We make sure you have the right equipment for your sport - and that it performs for you.

We can be reached by phone
Carmel, IN:  317-848-6044
Fishers, IN: 317-288-4632.

The Top Brands of New & Used Gear

Now in Two Convenient Northside Locations

Play It Again Sports in Carmel & Fishers proudly feature new and used sports equipment from these and other top name brands:

PlayItAgainSports-Carmel-Fishers logo collage

Looking for something in particlar?
Call or E-mail us to check on availability!

Contact us by E-Mail -
Carmel and Fishers Store: playcarmel@sbcglobal.net


We want your gently used sports equipment!

PIAS Carmel Most Wanted Used Items

Our ever-changing inventory of quality used sports gear is what makes Play It Again Sports in Fishers and Carmel so unique.

We're always paying cash on the spot for your unneeded or outgrown sporting goods. Or better yet, extend the value even more by taking a store credit.

Never pay full retail when you can create your own discount by trading in and trading up.

Let someone else in your community enjoy your equipment when you no longer need it and they can save, too.

Bring in that stuff in the garage that is no longer being used and turn it into what you really need!

Your Baseball/Softball Headquarters
Quality New & Used Gear
Fitness For Life
Snow Sports Specialists
Trade-In & Trade-Up
One Stop Hockey Shop


Your two Northside headquarters for new & used sports gear!!

PIAS Carmel store front
Our Carmel store is located in Merchant Square Shopping Center off Keystone Pkwy & 116th Street.

Store Hours: Mon-Fri 10 am to 7 pm, Saturday 10 am to 6 pm, and on Sunday 12 Noon to 5 pm. 

PIAS Fishers Store Front
The Fishers store is located at 116th Street and Olio Road, just North of Buffalo Wild Wings.

Store Hours: Mon-Fri 11 am to 8 pm, Saturday 10 am to 6 pm, and on Sunday 11 am to 4 pm. 



What's It Worth?

We are always looking to buy gently used gear.
Submit your gear and we will tell you what it is worth and if we can buy it.

Locker Talk: "He Got Traded."

See the latest commercials for Play It Again Sports on YouTube...

Hide This Message